Scientology’s Growing Influence on Clearwater’s Downtown Development Sparks Concern Among City Council Candidates

Clearwater, Florida, faces a significant turning point as the city council election approaches on March 19, with the influence of the Church of Scientology on downtown redevelopment emerging as a pivotal issue. Despite the reticence of most candidates to discuss the church’s impact directly, the election’s outcome will undoubtedly have major ramifications for both the city and the church.

In an investigative analysis by the Tampa Bay Times, it has been revealed that since 2017, limited liability companies (LLCs) controlled by Scientology parishioners have purchased at least 200 properties in downtown Clearwater and the adjacent North Marina area, spending around $163 million, predominantly in cash. This acquisition spree has left many buildings and storefronts vacant, creating a ghost town effect in areas the city has been trying to revitalize. Clearwater’s aggressive investment, including an $84 million renovation of Coachman Park, contrasts starkly with the deserted commercial buildings owned by entities tied to Scientology.

The ongoing negotiations between the city and the church, particularly over the proposed construction of L. Ron Hubbard Hall and potential land swaps or other deals to activate parishioner-controlled vacant properties, underscore the complex relationship between the two entities. City Manager Jennifer Poirrier’s discussions with church representatives aim to find a mutually beneficial agreement, although specific details have yet to be disclosed publicly.

The stance of city council candidates on how to address Scientology’s significant real estate holdings reflects a spectrum of views. Mayoral candidates Kathleen Beckman and Bruce Rector acknowledge the organized effort behind the property acquisitions, emphasizing the need for dialogue and strategic planning to balance downtown’s development. Incumbent council member Mark Bunker, known for his critical stance on Scientology, advocates for state and federal intervention, whereas candidate Mike Mastruserio suggests innovative approaches to circumvent the issue, like utilizing mobile retail units.

Other candidates, including Ryan Cotton, Jared Leone, Mike Mannino, and Javante Scott, offer various perspectives on dealing with the church’s influence, from enforcing commercial property vacancy taxes to promoting inclusive negotiations that involve all community stakeholders.

This situation in Clearwater highlights the broader challenges cities face when single entities, particularly religious organizations with opaque intentions, dominate local real estate markets. As Clearwater residents prepare to vote, the future of their downtown and the balance of power between the city and the Church of Scientology hang in the balance, signaling a critical juncture for community development and civic engagement.